Is it a good open world game? Sure
Is it an amazing game in it's own right? Eeeeehhhh...
Hot take: Forbidden West is the ONLY game where spending that much money on the graphics paid off. And it paid off, because a bunch of incels who've never seen a real woman complained about her peach fuzz and gave us all a laugh.
Yes. Literally the only real shortcoming is the Rebel post questline being repetitive. Excellent combat, story, characters, graphics and performance.. the list goes on. I loved all the cool story bits, so much memorable stuff. It's one of my favourite games ever. It was so much better as a sequel than Tears of the Kingdom, which I felt was a letdown. Also, its difficulty matched the setting I put it on, can you believe the game is challenging?
Oh, and that DLC was so good.