•

Deep-pocketed dairy industry continues war on plant-based milk as FDA hears comments on new draft guidance

Deep-pocketed dairy industry continues war on plant-based milk as FDA hears comments on new draft guidance - OpenSecrets News

https://www.opensecrets.org/news/2023/08/deep-pocketed-dairy-industry-continues-war-on-plant-based-milk-as-fda-hears-comments-on-new-draft-guidance

The dairy industry is using lobbying and viral marketing in an attempt to restrict the use of words like “milk” to animal products.

Deep-pocketed dairy industry continues war on plant-based milk as FDA hears comments on new draft guidance - OpenSecrets News

OpenSecrets.org

78 comments

See all comments

krayj

•

They are deep-pocketed, and they may be participating in a war, but certain words have technical definitions that are important to maintain when it comes to substances we ingest. Labeling anything as "milk" that did not come from the mammary glands of a mammal is technically wrong. Labeling anything as "mayonnaise" that isn't produced using poultry eggs is technically wrong. Labeling anything as "cheese" that isn't made from milk (see milk definition earlier) is technically wrong. Regardless of how evil you think these corporations are...they're not wrong in this case.

inasaba

•

People have been referring to white plant excretions as "milks" for hundreds of years. Coconut milk, milk of magnesia, etc. Hell, almond milk was a popular ingredient in the Middle Ages.

But you'll also notice that language has changed a lot since the Middle Ages. This is a natural process, and no amount of prescriptivism or pedantry will stop it. Calling things that are not dairy — but that we use in all of the exact same ways as dairy milk — "milks" is not a problem.

Nachorella

•

Yeah, just the other day I bought some chocolate eggs and when I went to fry them up for breakfast it turned out they were chocolate (wtf) this mis-labeling of things is just too confusing.

Streptember

•

The use of the word "milk" to refer to plant-based milks is older than the country in which this argument is occurring.

BrianTheFirst

•

How is it important to maintain the technical definition of the word?

speck

•

Well, you don't want language evolving do you??

CaptainAniki

•

Fo shizzle my nizzle! yeet!!

eatthecake

•

Some people actually read the packaging on their food and expect labels to be technically correct. You know, for informed decision making.

BrianTheFirst

•

Every alternative "milk" that I see at the store is clearly labeled "soy milk," "oat milk," etc. This is confusing to some people?

CaptainAniki

•

Milk thistle has entered the chat.

Followed by Milk of Magnesia.

markr

•

I agree that Kraft slices and whatever the fuck velveeta is should be banned from advertising themselves as cheese.

reverendsteveii

•

I'm on your side here but I also want to make platypus mayonnaise now just out of a sense of spite

krayj

•

This piqued my curiosity but I couldn't find any video. I'm now wondering if this is even possible and how weird it might look/taste.

Astroturfed

•

Shhhh you'll upset the vegans with your taste pleasure.

reverendsteveii

•

Dunking on vegans on the internet is equivalent to wearing a t shirt that says "I'm boring"

Astroturfed

•

Nice meaty asshole is my favorite flavor.