A cheap condom on a toy is usually a safe bet (sans material allergies) and a clean-up help. Unfortunately a bit wasteful, but not if health is on the line.
My searching with Qwant lead to rather negative results:
Howewer I can't vouch for the sites, only on general of phalates toxicity, problems with porousness and hygiene, and problems with cheap materials.
So either go with a condom, or accept you have a conversation starter to display ;)
Thank you so much! I guess I'll just look for some cheap condoms to buy and look for a new one when I get the chance. I'm definitely staying away from that site... I'd rather go to a sex shop when I get the chance, and pick something up which I'm certain will be safe!
Really sucks there aren't any regulations regarding this – you'd think buying something from a well-known site would be at least nontoxic – Oh, well...